The road to the Pro Football Hall of Fame is usually a red carpet for quarterbacks with two Super Bowl rings and legendary statistics. However, for Ben Roethlisberger, that “first-ballot” opportunity in 2027 is beginning to look more like a minefield.
Following the recent and surprising snub of Bill Belichick, who was left out of the Class of 2026, doubts have started to grow over whether “Big Ben’s” legacy will be enough to convince the selection committee. The panel not only excluded the longtime New England head coach but also overlooked Patriots owner Robert Kraft, raising fresh questions about how strict the standards have become.
The analysis of an increasingly rigorous Hall of Fame
Historically, Roethlisberger’s numbers are beyond dispute: 64,088 passing yards and 418 touchdowns, totals that place him in the all-time top 10. Add to that his two Super Bowl victories (XL and XLIII) and six Pro Bowl selections. On paper, there should be little controversy, yet recent voting decisions have made any projection far more uncertain.
Still, analysts such as Mike Florio suggest the wait could be lengthy. The selection committee has recently shown that on-field accomplishments alone are not always enough to overlook other considerations, including matters that may extend into a candidate’s private life.
Roethlisberger will face fierce competition in his first year of eligibility from figures such as Adrian Peterson and Rob Gronkowski. Yet his most significant hurdle may not be statistical comparison, but rather questions about “character” and overall impact on the integrity of the game, a benchmark that has already affected other legends.
The “Belichick Effect” and the weight of personal allegations
The risk for Roethlisberger lies in a recent precedent: Belichick. Despite owning eight Super Bowl rings, the former Patriots coach failed to secure the 40 votes required out of a possible 50 for induction. Controversies such as Spygate and Deflategate weakened his candidacy. In Roethlisberger’s case, the concern does not stem from competitive infractions, but from internal accounts that challenge his personal conduct and leadership qualities.
Recently, his former teammate Joey Porter Sr. delivered sharp criticism on the podcast Not Just Football: “He’s a bad person. I won a Super Bowl with him, but as a person? He’s just not a good teammate.” Porter claimed that Roethlisberger would even refuse to sign autographs for teammates’ family members, leading the locker room to stop voting him as captain.
Those remarks have reportedly been echoed by other players, including Mason Rudolph. Meanwhile, Shannon Sharpe warned on his podcast Nightcap that a first-ballot induction will be difficult: “Everyone knew things that weren’t reported… it’s going to be tough.”
If the Hall of Fame committee applies the same “integrity” standard that halted Belichick’s candidacy, Roethlisberger’s 18 years of success in Pittsburgh may not be enough to prevent a prolonged and frustrating wait. At the same time, such a decision would once again spark debate over the criteria and consistency of the Hall of Fame itself.