With just one touch of the football, 16-year-old Antonio Arena became the centre of arguably the biggest question in Australian sport this week.
Could this prodigy be the future of the Socceroos?
Watch the biggest Aussie sports & the best from overseas LIVE on Kayo Sports | New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1.
Sydney-born Arena is set to be pitted into a tug of war that will feel all-too-familiar for Australian football fans.
He could one day be the most talented striker to pull on the green and gold since Mark Viduka — or he could be the latest to slip through Australian fingers, like legendary striker Christian Vieri, or former Croatia stalwart Josip Simunic.
Barely able to legally drive a car, Arena made global headlines this week with his senior debut for Italian giants Roma.
At 16 years, 11 months and 3 days, Arena was an 80th-minute substitute for the Serie A side in its Round of 16 Coppa Italia clash against Torino.
On the field for less than two minutes, and with his first-ever pro touch for Roma, Arena did the unthinkable when he headed the ball past the goalkeeper and sent Stadio Olimpico into raptures.
“Perhaps we are witnessing the rise of a new star,” the commentator said amid the epic celebrations.
Sky Italy said that after the goal, “a young phenomenon was born”.
Anyone unfamiliar with the towering Aussie teenager, and his quiet rise abroad, was in the dark no longer.
The story went global, not just making headlines in Italy and Australia, but also Stateside with USA Today writing about his dream debut.
And why wouldn’t they? In nodding home, Arena became the equal third-youngest scorer in Roma history. The feat adds to the record he made for Pescara at 16 years and 25 days, when he became the youngest player to ever score for the club, eclipsing Marco Verrati’s record.
Naturally, hopes are running high that Arena could one day blossom into the type of goal freak that the Socceroos have rarely seen.
But, as has often proven to be the case in Australian mens football, there’s a snag.
He might already be spoken for.
Read the tea leaves and they suggest that Arena is angling for a future with the Italian national team instead.
Though born in Sydney — coming through the Marconi ranks before joining the Western Sydney Wanderers Academy — Arena holds both Australian and Italian citizenships with his grandparents from Reggio Calabria.
He has represented Australia at U-16 level, making his debut in a friendly against Switzerland in 2024.
However, he has more often, and more recently, played for Italy, where he moved as a 13-year-old. Arena has played for the Azzurri across U-16, 17 and 18 age groups, including being picked for last year’s U-17 World Cup.
Meanwhile, an article published in La Gazzetta dello Sport after Arena’s Roma debut hinted that he has already committed to his Italian dream.
“He continues to receive offers from Australia to wear the national team jersey,” the article says. “Risk is imminent.
“But the pride of Italy prevails. Especially since his mother and sister are now moving to Rome: all together for this dream in yellow and red. And in blue.”
It’s a dream fellow Sydney-born youngster Cristian Volpato is chasing, too, after he famously turned down an offer from Socceroos coach Graham Arnold to go to the 2022 World Cup.
Volpato has played for Italy at U-19, 20 and 21 level, but is yet to realise his dream of being called up to the senior side, leaving the door open to a Socceroos U-turn.
Early indications suggest Arena also has his eggs in the Italian basket. Last year he told the Italian federation’s official website “The Azzurri jersey always brings up lots of emotions for me and I am honoured to wear it.”
At just 16, however, Arena has far more time on his side to decide where his international allegiance will eventually lie, while there’s the potential for roadblocks to emerge and influence his call.
Should Australia ultimately prevail, however, the Socceroos would have their hands on an unbelievable talent, according to those who know his game best.
Speaking to Sky Italy this week, Pescara Business Development Director Marco Arcese offered a stunning comparison to Italian giants when asked about Arena.
“I think he’s a cross between Vieri and (Filippo) Inzaghi,” he told the network. “Vieri in terms of his physicality and the way he attacks the space, but I think he has Inzaghi’s ability to run free.
“He scored a great goal against Torino … It’s something he has inside him.
“He’s a guy who sees the goal like few others, he’s always in the right place at the right time.”
His incredible praise follows similar comparisons last year by the Italian media, who compared Arena to the likes of Erling Haaland and even Cristiano Ronaldo.
“As a child, he studied Ronaldo the Phenomenon; today, he resembles another Ronaldo, CR7, the Portuguese one. For certain moves on the pitch, and above all for his dedication to work,” Andrea Barilaro wrote in La Gazzetta dello Sport.
Meanwhile, Arcese said he hoped that Roma coach Gian Piero Gasperini would invest further in Arena, who was initially signed for a reported €1 million (A$1.8m approx.).
Speaking after the Torino match, Gasperini singled out Arena for some lofty praise.
“I’m happy about these very young players: one is 16 years old and it’s an important process for him,” Gasperini said.
Salah denied final after late winner! | 00:56
“He is certainly a player who has a great competitive drive, despite his young age. He has a lot of energy to offer and he’s not afraid to put himself out there.”
An intriguing few years lie ahead with Arena’s progress sure to be closely monitored by both the Italian and Australian international teams.
Whether Arena could be swayed towards a homecoming is too early to say.
But what’s certain is that the striker is aiming high and will stop at nothing to realise his immense potential.
“It was a wonderful, unforgettable feeling (scoring) … Nothing is going to change from today onwards,” he told the Roma website after his debut.
“I want to become as good a player as possible. I want to work hard all the time.
“I’ve already made some improvements, but I still have a lot to learn. I’m happy I scored, but nothing has changed.”