When the Kansas City Chiefs agreed on Monday to sign former Seattle Seahawks running back Kenneth Walker III, the move immediately raised an intriguing historical question across the NFL. For decades, players who captured Super Bowl MVP honors and then left their teams in free agency the following season have struggled to replicate their success elsewhere.
But with Walker now becoming the fourth player in league history to make that move, the spotlight will be on whether he can finally break what some fans have begun calling the “Super Bowl MVP curse.”
Walker earned his Super Bowl LX MVP award after delivering a dominant performance in the Seattle Seahawks‘ 29-13 victory over the New England Patriots.
The star running back rushed for 135 yards and added 26 receiving yards in a game that cemented his place in franchise lore.
Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs former rival could be their answer at running back
Despite that success, Walker agreed to join the Kansas City Chiefs during the opening phase of the league’s legal tampering window.
Once the new league year officially begins, the deal is expected to become a three-year contract worth $45 million, with more than $28 million guaranteed.
While the signing strengthens the Chiefs‘ offensive backfield, history suggests that the transition may not be easy.
A pattern of Super Bowl MVP struggles
The first example of this trend dates back to the mid-1990s. In Super Bowl XXX, Larry Brown delivered a memorable defensive performance for the Dallas Cowboys, intercepting two passes to help defeat the Pittsburgh Steelers 27-17.
Shortly after the championship victory, Brown signed a five-year, $12.5 million contract with the Oakland Raiders. The move was seen as a major acquisition for owner Al Davis.
Former Raiders CEO Amy Trask, who is now an analyst with CBS Sports, later recalled how quickly the organization pursued the deal.
“Al said to me innumerable times throughout my career: ‘Kid, never leave a team without corners,'” Trask told Athlon Sports.
“It thus did not surprise me that we signed Larry and in fact, immediately after the Super Bowl, I told my husband that I was confident we would.”
She added: “Al didn’t hesitate to do so. He was committed to getting this done.”
However, the signing ultimately failed to deliver the impact Oakland expected.
Brown played only eight games over two seasons before being waived prior to the 1998 campaign. He later returned to the Dallas Cowboys late that same year before retiring. The following season, another Super Bowl MVP experienced a similar outcome.
After leading the Green Bay Packers to a 35-21 victory over the New England Patriots in Super Bowl XXXI, return specialist Desmond Howard earned MVP honors thanks to a record-setting 244 combined punt and kickoff return yards, including a 99-yard touchdown.
Like Brown, Howard signed with the Oakland Raiders in free agency.
He agreed to a four-year, $6 million contract but lasted just two seasons before being released. Howard eventually returned to the Green Bay Packers in 1999.
Jackson follows suit
The third example occurred after Dexter Jackson helped the Tampa Bay Buccaneers defeat the Oakland Raiders 48-21 in Super Bowl XXXVII.
Following that victory, Jackson signed a five-year, $14 million contract with the Arizona Cardinals.
Although his first season showed promise, injuries derailed his tenure. A bulging disc in his back kept him off the field in 2004, and he was eventually released before returning to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He later finished his career with the Cincinnati Bengals.
Each of those previous Super Bowl MVPs ended up rejoining their original championship teams within two years.
Now, with Walker preparing to begin a new chapter with the Kansas City Chiefs, the question remains whether he can finally rewrite that history.